RBI’s Sovereign Gold Bonds 5th Tranche – Series II – FY 2016-17 – September 2016 Issue

This post is written by Shiv Kukreja, who is a Certified Financial Planner and runs a financial planning firm, Ojas Capital in Delhi/NCR. He can be reached at [email protected]

As gold prices go up, more and more people start investing in gold in the hope of prices going up further. This has always been the case and seems this trend will continue in future as well. To cash it on this trend and cap purchase of physical gold, the government has launched its 5th tranche of Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) from September 1, 2016. This will be the second such issue in the current financial year and fifth overall since it was first introduced in November 2015.

Notified as Series II of the current financial year, this issue is open till September 9th. Below are the salient features of this bond issue:

Salient Features of Sovereign Gold Bonds – Series I of FY 2016-17

Picture1

Issue Price – As the price of gold in the international market has risen after Brexit, price for this tranche has been fixed at its highest level of Rs. 3,150 per gram of gold. Issue price for the first tranche was fixed at Rs. 2,684 per gram of gold, that of the second tranche was Rs. 2,600 per gram of gold, it was Rs. 2,916 per gram of gold in the third tranche and Rs. 3,116 per gram of gold in the fourth tranche.

The government could raise only Rs. 246 crore from its first issue in November issuing bonds with around 916 kg of gold, Rs. 798 crore from the second issue in January with around 3,071 kg gold, Rs. 329 crore from the third issue in March with around 1,128 kg gold and Rs. 919 crore from the fourth issue in July.

Issue Price Methodology – The issue price of Rs. 3,150 per gram of gold has been fixed on the basis of simple average of the closing prices of gold with 999 purity of the previous week (August 22, 2016 to August 26, 2016) published by the India Bullion and Jewellers Association Ltd. (IBJA).

Coupon Rate @ 2.75% p.a. –  As always, interest rate has been fixed at 2.75% p.a. to be paid twice in a year. Apart from this fixed rate of 2.75%, there is a potential of capital appreciation with these bonds and also a risk of decline in gold prices. Fall in gold prices would result in a negative yield from capital gains point of view, but 2.75% p.a. interest would remain fixed throughout its tenor of 8 years.

Allotment Date & Tenor of Investment – As per the RBI, these bonds would get allotted on 23rd of September and carry a maturity period of 8 years from the allotment date. However, there is an option to surrender these bonds from the 5th year onwards. Option to redeem will be there in the 5th, 6th and 7th year of investment only on the interest payment dates.

Delay in Allotment & Listing – Investors should have low expectations from the RBI to get these gold bonds allotted in a timely manner on September 23rd. No issue in the past got allotted on time as promised. There is no grievance redressal mechanism in place to help you either. So, if you apply for these bonds now, you might again be required to have a lot of patience in getting them allotted and see their listing in a timely manner.

Demat Option Available – Like its fourth tranche, you have the option to get these bonds allotted in demat form as well. Introduction of demat facility should bring down the time taken to allot these bonds and get them listed on the stock exchanges for trading.

Tradability, ISIN & Exit Option Before 5 years – As mentioned above, these bonds are redeemable from the 5th year onwards. However, in order to provide liquidity to its investors before 5th year, the government and RBI have made provisions for these bonds to list on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and National Stock Exchange (NSE). These exchanges have allotted ISIN as well to these bonds, which is IN0020160043. You can sell your gold bonds on these stock exchanges after they get allotted on or after September 23rd.

In order to carry out premature redemption after 5 years, investors would be required to approach the concerned intermediary 30 days before the coupon payment date. This request for premature redemption would only be entertained if the investor approaches the concerned intermediary at least one day before the coupon payment date. Redemption proceeds will be credited to the customer’s bank account.

Online Bidding Platforms Launched – During its last issue, RBI introduced online bidding platforms for these gold bonds with BSE and NSE. Applying for these bonds has become a lot easier now with these platforms in place. These platforms will remain open till 12 a.m. on September 9th. There is a cooling off period of 30 minutes from 5:30 p.m. to 6 p.m. everyday.

Taxation in case of Redemption/Sale – Sovereign gold bonds are subject to capital gains tax treatment from FY 2016-17 onwards and gains are tax exempt if these bonds are redeemed after 5 years. Moreover, if these bonds are sold on the stock exchanges after 3 years from the allotment date, indexation benefits can be availed to calculate your capital gain or loss.

As per the Budget speech “It is proposed to provide that redemption by an individual of Sovereign Gold Bond issued by Reserve Bank of India under Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme, 2015 shall not be charged to capital gains tax. It is also proposed to provide that long terms capital gains arising to any person on transfer of Sovereign Gold Bond shall be eligible for indexation benefits”.

So, as an individual, whenever you redeem these gold bonds after holding them for 5 years, you are not liable to pay any capital gains tax. Indexation benefit will also result in a substantial tax saving.

No TDS, Interest @ 2.75% is Taxable – Interest income earned every year @ 2.75% p.a. is taxable and it is the responsibility of the investors to show it as an income from other sources in their income tax returns (ITRs). No TDS (tax deducted at source) will be deducted by the RBI while making interest payments.

Minimum and Maximum Investment – Like its last issue, investors are required to buy a minimum of 1 unit of these bonds i.e. 1 gram of gold or a minimum investment of Rs. 3,150. However, you can buy a maximum of 500 units of these bonds or 500 grams of gold, which works out to be Rs. 15,75,000.

NRI/QFI Investment Not Allowed – Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) and Qualified Foreign Investors (QFIs) are not eligible to invest in these bonds. Only resident Indian entities, including individuals, trusts, universities and charitable institutions are eligible to invest in these bonds.

Transferability – These bonds can also be transferred by execution of an instrument of transfer, in accordance with the provisions of the Government Securities Act.

Collateral for Loans – If required, these bonds can be used as collateral for seeking loans from various lending institutions.

Sovereign Gold Bonds vs. Gold ETF vs. Physical Gold – A Comparative Chart

Picture3

Should you invest in Sovereign Gold Bonds – Series I, FY 2016-17?

Gold is considered to be a hedge against inflation, recession and other times of uncertainties. It is also considered to be a safe haven for investors, that is why investors put more money in gold during volatile economic conditions. Moreover, when the global economies get stronger and the US dollar strengthens, investors move their investments away from gold.

As the US Federal Reserve is set to raise its policy rates sooner or later due to a stronger than expected jobs market, I think the gold prices should weaken going forward. However, investors with a bullish stance on gold prices and a medium to long-term investment horizon can consider investing in these bonds. As it is the cheapest, most tax efficient, risk-free way of investing in gold, I think this way of investing in gold is the best way. If your portfolio does not have gold as an investment, then you should definitely go for it, albeit in a staggered way.

Sovereign Gold Bonds – Series I – FY 2016-17 – July 2016 Issue

This post is written by Shiv Kukreja, who is a Certified Financial Planner and runs a financial planning firm, Ojas Capital in Delhi/NCR. He can be reached at [email protected]

After three unsuccessful attempts of raising any meaningful amount of money from the investors by issuing its gold bonds, the government is launching its fourth tranche of Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) from today onwards i.e. July 18, 2016. This will be the first such issue in the current financial year and that is why it has been notified as Series I of FY 2016-17. The issue will remain open for five days from today to close on July 22.

To make it more attractive, the government and the RBI have made certain changes this time around. Below is the table having salient features of these bonds, some of which are different from its previous issues.

Salient Features of Sovereign Gold Bonds – Series I of FY 2016-17

Picture1

Issue Price – Price for this tranche has been fixed at Rs. 3,119 per gram of gold, which is substantially higher than the price of these bonds in the previous three issues. Issue price for the first tranche was fixed at Rs. 2,684 per gram of gold, that of the second tranche was Rs. 2,600 per gram of gold and it was Rs. 2,916 per gram of gold in the third tranche.

The government could raise only Rs. 246 crore from its first issue in November issuing bonds with around 916 kg of gold, Rs. 798 crore from the second issue in January with around 3,071 kg gold and Rs. 329 crore from the third issue in March with around 1,128 kg gold.

Issue Price Methodology – The issue price of Rs. 3,119 per gram of gold has been fixed on the basis of simple average of the closing prices of gold with 999 purity of the previous week (July 11, 2016 to July 15, 2016) published by the India Bullion and Jewellers Association Ltd. (IBJA).

Coupon Rate @ 2.75% p.a. –  As in earlier tranches, coupon rate has been fixed at 2.75% p.a. payable semi-annually i.e. twice in a year. As mentioned earlier as well, these bonds offer two streams of return – one in the form of regular interest income @ 2.75% and the other in the form of increase or decrease in the market price of gold. A decline in their price would result in a negative yield from capital gains point of view, but 2.75% p.a. interest would remain fixed throughout its tenor of 8 years.

Allotment Date & Tenor of Investment – These bonds would get allotted on 5th of August and carry a maturity period of 8 years from the allotment date. However, the investors can ask for redemption of their bond holdings from the 5th year onwards. This option will be available for the investors in the 5th, 6th and 7th year of investment only on the interest payment dates.

Demat Option Available Now – In its previous issues, you were allowed to apply for these bonds in physical form only. But, in order to cut the allotment/listing time, the government has allowed to introduce the demat option as well. Now, you can get these bonds allotted directly into your damat account.

Tradability & Exit Option Before 5 years – These bonds are redeemable back to the RBI, but only from 5th year onwards. But, what to do if I want my money back in an emergency? So, in that case, you can sell these bonds on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) or the National Stock Exchange (NSE) where they will get listed for trading after allotment.

However, previous issues of these bonds have faced a considerable delay in the allotment and listing of these bonds. Redressal mechanism of your grievances is also considerably poor. So, if you apply for these bonds now, you might again be required to have a lot of patience in getting them allotted and see their listing in a timely manner.

Online Bidding Platforms Launched – BSE and NSE have also launched their respective online bidding platforms for these gold bonds. With these platforms in place, applying for these bonds should become easier now. These bidding platforms will remain open for all 24 hours in a day for the next 5 days to close on July 22 at 12 midnight time. There will be a cooling off period of 30 minutes from 5:30 p.m. to 6 p.m.

Premature Redemption – In case of premature redemption (after 5 years), investors can approach the concerned intermediary 30 days before the coupon payment date. Request for premature redemption can only be entertained if the investor approaches the concerned intermediary at least one day before the coupon payment date. Redemption proceeds will be credited to the customer’s bank account.

Taxation in case of Redemption/Sale – Finance Minister Arun Jaitley in his budget speech had proposed to make these bonds tax exempt if redeemed after 5 years. These bonds also enjoy indexation benefits if sold after 3 years from the allotment date. As per the Budget speech “It is proposed to provide that redemption by an individual of Sovereign Gold Bond issued by Reserve Bank of India under Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme, 2015 shall not be charged to capital gains tax. It is also proposed to provide that long terms capital gains arising to any person on transfer of Sovereign Gold Bond shall be eligible for indexation benefits”.

So, as an individual, whenever you redeem these gold bonds after holding them for 5 years, you are not liable to pay capital gains tax. Indexation benefit will also result in a substantial tax saving.

Interest @ 2.75% is Taxable – Interest income earned every year @ 2.75% p.a. is taxable and the investors will have to show it as an Income from Other Sources in their income tax returns (ITRs).

Minimum and Maximum Investment – Investors are required to buy a minimum of 1 units of these bonds i.e. 1 gram of gold or a minimum investment of Rs. 3,119. In the previous issues, you were required to buy a minimum of 2 units of these bonds. On the other hand, you can buy a maximum of 500 units of these bonds or 500 grams of gold, which works out to be Rs. 15,59,500.

NRI/QFI Investment Not Allowed – Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) and Qualified Foreign Investors (QFIs) are not eligible to invest in these bonds. Only Resident Indian Entities, including individuals, trusts, universities and charitable institutions are eligible to invest in these bonds.

Transferability – Though these bonds are tradable, trading is allowed only once it is notified by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). Bonds can be transferred also by execution of an Instrument of Transfer, in accordance with the provisions of the Government Securities Act.

Collateral for Loans – If required, these bonds can be used as collateral for seeking loans from various lending institutions.

Sovereign Gold Bonds vs. Gold ETF vs. Physical Gold – A Comparative Chart

Picture1

When I compare these bonds with Gold ETFs or physical gold, I am not able to find any point which goes against these bonds, except liquidity. As you can check from the table above, almost all the points of comparison are in favour of these bonds.

Should you invest in Sovereign Gold Bonds – Series I, FY 2016-17?

An uncertain global economic environment amid Brexit concerns, China slowdown, weak US jobs data and upcoming presidential elections in the US has pushed up the prices of gold in the last six months or so. But, whether this jump in gold prices will be able to sustain itself or is it a good time to sell your gold holdings and preserve your profits? These are million dollar questions to be answered with a high degree of accuracy.

Though I am bearish on gold prices and carry a view that these are not the best of the times to invest in gold, investors with a bullish view and a medium to long-term investment horizon can consider investing in these bonds. This way of investing in gold is cheap, tax efficient, risk-free in terms of a credit default and do provide you a stream of regular cash flows. If your portfolio has some scope of gold investment, I think these bonds are the best way to invest in gold.

Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme – Tranche III – March 2016 Issue

This post is written by Shiv Kukreja, who is a Certified Financial Planner and runs a financial planning firm, Ojas Capital in Delhi/NCR. He can be reached at [email protected]

The government is doing all it could do to curb the demand as well as imports of physical gold, but the government is yet to understand the psychology of people living here in India. We love our country, but we do not leave any chance to spread litter on our roads, parks and all other places wherever we can. We want ‘Azaadi’ within India, despite having all the Azaadi to burn and destroy public and private properties and commit the most condemnable offences such as rapes, murders etc.

We are very patriotic, but we do not leave any chance to leave our country and spend a comfortable life outside India for the rest of our life cursing the Indian systems. We consider Indian culture to be the best, but we do not leave any chance to make fun of our Prime Ministers.

To cut it short, we need to understand that if any of our measures are not working in our favour to achieve any of our targets, we need to rework on our strategy to achieve it and that is what the government has not been able to do in case of its flagship gold scheme – Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme. Despite the gold investment giving negative returns in the past two years or so, the lure of buying gold in India is not going down and the government has failed to curb the demand of physical gold.

After two consecutive unsuccessful attempts, the government will be launching its third tranche of gold bonds from Tuesday, 8th of March. The scheme will remain open till March 14 and the bonds will be issued on March 29, 2016.

Here are some important features of this scheme:

Issue Price – The investors can invest in these bonds at Rs. 2,916 per gram of gold. The issue price this time is higher than the previous two issues. Issue price for the first tranche was fixed at Rs. 2,684 per gram of gold and that of the second tranche was Rs. 2,600 per gram of gold.

The government could raise only Rs. 246 crore from its first issue in November issuing bonds with around 916 kg of gold and Rs. 798 crore from the second issue in January issuing bonds with around 3,071 kg of gold.

Issue Price Methodology – The issue price has been fixed on the basis of simple average of closing price for gold of 999 purity of the previous week (February 29, 2016 to March 4, 2016) published by the India Bullion and Jewellers Association Ltd. (IBJA).

Coupon Rate @ 2.75% p.a. – Sovereign Gold Bonds offer two streams of returns – one in the form of regular interest income @ 2.75% per annum payable semi-annually and the other in the form of increase or decrease in the market price of gold.

Tenor of Investment – These bonds will be issued for a period of 8 years from the allotment date, which is March 29, 2016, with an exit option from the 5th year on the interest payment dates.

Premature Redemption – In case of premature redemption (after 5 years), investors can approach the concerned intermediary 30 days before the coupon payment date. Request for premature redemption can only be entertained if the investor approaches the concerned intermediary at least one day before the coupon payment date. Redemption proceeds will be credited to the customer’s bank account.

Taxation – Budget 2016 has tried to make these bonds more attractive from taxation point of view. As per the Budget speech “It is proposed to provide that redemption by an individual of Sovereign Gold Bond issued by Reserve Bank of India under Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme, 2015 shall not be charged to capital gains tax. It is also proposed to provide that long terms capital gains arising to any person on transfer of Sovereign Gold Bond shall be eligible for indexation benefits”.

So, as an individual, whenever you redeem these gold bonds after holding them for 5 years, you are not liable to pay any capital gain tax.

Minimum and Maximum Investment – Investors are required to buy a minimum of 2 units of these bonds i.e. 2 grams of gold or a minimum investment of Rs. 5,832. On the other hand, you can buy a maximum of 500 units of these bonds or 500 grams of gold, which works out to be Rs. 14,58,000.

NRI/QFI Investment Not Allowed – Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) and Qualified Foreign Investors (QFIs) are not eligible to invest in these bonds. Only Resident Indian Entities, including individuals, trusts, universities and charitable institutions are eligible to invest in these bonds.

Transferability – Though these bonds are tradable, but trading is allowed only once it is notified by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). Bonds can be transferred also by execution of an Instrument of Transfer, in accordance with the provisions of the Government Securities Act.

Sovereign Gold Bonds vs. Gold ETF vs. Physical Gold – A Comparative Chart

Picture1

As you can check from the table above, almost all the points of comparison are in favour of these Sovereign Gold Bonds, except the liquidity thing. That too, I think is not a big issue as and when the RBI notifies these bonds to trade on the stock exchanges. So, if you are bullish about the gold prices rising from hereon and/or if your asset allocation permits you to invest in gold or gold derivatives, I think there cannot be any better option other than these Sovereign Gold Bonds. Personally, I think the government should first cut high import duties on gold to make them attractive for me from investment point of view.

Do you think these gold bonds make a good investment option for you? If ‘Yes’, please share why you think so. If ‘No’, please let us know why you think so. Also, in case you think I have missed anything in the post above, please let me know. I will incorporate that point in the article as soon as possible.

Gold funds versus Gold ETFs

2013 has been tough for gold ETFs and gold fund of funds so far, and it also happens to be the only six or seven month time period when gold funds have been down. This gives us a good opportunity to see if gold funds behave differently from gold ETFs during down periods.

Last year I had done a post on the best performing gold ETFs and gold funds and one of the clear trends in that was that gold ETFs gave slightly better returns than gold mutual funds. This is because gold mutual funds have an added expense layer on top of the expenses that the ETFs have to incur. However, there is no brokerage or transaction cost if you buy a mutual fund as opposed to an ETF and this is where gold funds have an edge on gold ETFs. You can also do a SIP comparatively easier on gold funds, and this is another aspect where gold funds score over gold ETFs.

In the six month period so far the trend of gold ETFs doing better than gold funds has been reversed and I find that gold funds have fallen slightly lesser than gold ETFs. Here is the data from Value Research. 

Name 6 Month Return
 ICICI Prudential Regular Gold Savings -17.53
 SBI Gold -17.61
 Quantum Gold Savings -17.9
 Axis Gold -18.05
 HDFC Gold -18.09
 ICICI Prudential Gold ETF -18.2
 R*Shares Gold ETF -18.31
 Canara Robeco Gold Savings Regular -18.34
 Birla Sun Life Gold ETF -18.35
 Religare Invesco Gold -18.44
 Quantum Gold -18.5
 Religare Invesco Gold ETF -18.52
 Axis Gold ETF -18.54
 Goldman Sachs Gold ETF -18.56
 Canara Robeco Gold ETF -18.58
 IDBI Gold -18.6
 UTI Gold ETF -18.62
 SBI Gold ETS -18.64
 HDFC Gold ETF -18.65
 IDBI Gold ETF -18.66
 Kotak Gold ETF -18.67
 Motilal Oswal MOSt Shares Gold ETF -18.69
 Kotak Gold -18.7
 Reliance Gold Savings -18.71
 Birla Sun Life Gold -19.05

As you can see, generally, gold fund of funds have fared better than gold ETFs, and I think this may be because gold fund of funds have a little bit of extra cash parked in fixed income securities to help with redemptions that gold ETFs do not. I can’t think of any other reason why this could be the case.

When gold fund of funds were first introduced I felt that investing in ETFs directly was much better but as time has gone by I have realized that there is very little difference between the two and if you are a small investor then you are better off with gold fund of funds as you save on transaction charges and SIPs are easy to set up.

Having seen these two products since their launch, I now feel that gold fund of funds have an edge over gold ETFs for most small investors.

Tanishq Gold Harvest Scheme Review

Manish Chauhan wrote about gold saving schemes recently and he briefly mentioned Tanishq Gold Harvest scheme in his article and I thought this was an interesting product.

Main Benefit of a Gold Savings Scheme

In the past when I’ve heard about gold savings schemes from jewelers, the primary benefit is that they allow you to save up monthly and build a substantial sum over a period of time, and they also allow you to lock in to the gold price that is prevailing at the time of your installment.

So, if you started the scheme today, they would lock down today’s rate at least for the amount of the installment you pay. This has been useful in the past with gold’s steady march upwards, and is a good thing for people who know they will need to buy jewelry at a certain date.

Tanishq Gold Harvest Scheme Key Benefit

The Tanishq Gold Harvest Scheme differs from these other type of schemes in that sense because they don’t lock down a price for you but instead sell you the jewelry at the rate prevailing at the end of the scheme.

Why lock down your money with them at all then?

The benefit of this scheme is that they give you a discount of sorts, where you pay 11 installments, and then Tanishq pays the 12th installment for you. I’ve seen some articles use the simple interest calculation but that’s not the correct way to calculate the return on this. You need to use IRR to calculate the return as BasuNivesh has rightly done, and I see that the annualized return on this type of this is about 19%.

This is a really good return, and you won’t find a similar rate in recurring deposits which to me is the comparable product.

So, if you knew you wanted to buy gold jewelry from Tanishq in the future, I would say this is a handy scheme and that’s perhaps the reason it has 15 lakh customers already.

Disadvantages of Tanishq Gold Harvest Scheme

The disadvantages of this scheme are fairly obvious too.

You are locked in with Tanishq, and can’t buy jewelry from anywhere else; you get the rate of a later date even though you are paying money in advance.

You don’t have the option of stopping the scheme mid way and take your money back once you start the scheme, you have to complete it and then buy the jewelry.

Who is this scheme suitable for?

Thinking of all these factors, I think the Tanishq Gold Harvest Scheme is ideal for people who are planning to buy gold from Tanishq in the future anyway. Save a little every month, and take advantage of their bonus.

For people who want to buy gold jewelry in the future but don’t care if it is from Tanishq or others, I’d say this can still be a better option than a jeweler who lets you lock down on the day’s rate but that would depend on how much you think gold will appreciate in the next year.

For people who want to buy gold as an investment, I’ve never felt jewelry was a great option because of the making charges, and the loss you incur when you go to sell it back, and you should instead look for options to own gold coins or gold ETFs, e-Gold etc.